Pete’s Paleo VS ICON Meals Comparison
Advertiser Disclosure
This website features affiliate links. For purchases made via these links, we earn commissions that allow us to keep producing helpful content. To find out more click here. Close
No one understands how important it is to choose the right meal delivery service better than we do. That is why we are here to help you make the best possible choice. While both ICON Meals and Pete's Paleo offer delicious dishes and rather flexible subscriptions, there is much more to be considered before you make the final call. This ICON Meals VS Pete's Paleo comparison allows you to get to know these companies better, discover their greatest advantages and shortcomings, and of course, find out which one provides a bit higher quality of service.
VS
Highlights
ICON Meals is here to help you achieve your health and fitness goals with much less effort. Order subscription-free and choose from a vast assortment of chef-designed meals, custom-made dishes, protein snacks, and cooked proteins, carbs, and veg sold by the pound.
- Price Range: $
- Average Price Per Meal: $9.00
- Shipping Cost: $15.00 - $50+ *
- Delivery Area: 50 states and Puerto Rico
*Shipping costs vary depending on location and order value
Pete’s Paleo allows you to enjoy delicious organic chef-prepared Paleo meals and decide on everything from meal selection and quantity to portion size and delivery frequency.
- Price Range: $$
- Average Price Per Meal: $15.62
- Shipping Cost: $0
- Delivery Area: 50 states
Compare Features
Best For
Best for fitness enthusiasts
Menu/Meal Plans
ICON Meals does not offer meal plans. Instead, it lets you freely choose items from its rich menu.
Recipes/Meal Options
ICON Meals features over 50 items on its menu.
Meal & Recipe Variety
ICON Meals provides breakfasts, lunches, dinners, snacks, and meal components including proteins, carbs, and vegetables. Its selection includes gluten-free, low-carb, low-sodium, low-sugar, vegan-friendly, and vegetarian items.
Food Quality
ICON Meals uses only natural, locally sourced ingredients. It delivers fresh meals free from preservatives and unhealthy artificial additives.
Nutritional Value & Portion Size
ICON Meals dishes contain 250-550 calories per serving. They generally come in portions ranging from 5 to 10 ounces, but you can customize your meals to increase your portion size. All the meals are nutritionally balanced and approved by an in-house dietitian.
Subscription Flexibility
ICON Meals lets you order without a subscription, as often as you please, with no minimum order threshold. However, it does not allow you to change your order after it has been placed.
Refunds
If you are not happy with your ICON Meals order, you can request a refund via phone or email within 24 hours after delivery. You may be required to provide photographic evidence in order to receive a refund.
Best For
Best for Paleo lovers and people on high-protein, low-carb diets
Menu/Meal Plans
With Pete's Paleo, you can choose from its Weekly Menu, Lite Menu, and Eat What You Love Menu. You can also opt for its 21-Day Sugar Detox.
Recipes/Meal Options
If you opt for Pete's Paleo Weekly Menu, you can receive 5, 10 or 14 meals every week or every other week. With Pete's Paleo Lite Menu, you will receive 7 meals every week or every other week. If you choose the Eat What You Love Menu, you can choose from 16 meal options on the menu every week. You can recieve 7, 14 or 21 meals with the 21-Day Sigar Detox.
Meal & Recipe Variety
All meals on the Pete’s Paleo menu are organic, gluten-free, dairy-free, soy-free, and Paleo-friendly. The service also offers keto-friendly, vegetarian, light, and low-carb meals, as well as AIP-friendly, sugar-free, and low-FODMAP dishes.
Food Quality
Pete’s Paleo closely works with its farmers and suppliers to provide its customers with food of the absolute highest quality. It uses only organically grown produce free on GMOs or any other harmful substances and pasture-raised and grass-fed meat. Its food contains no dairy, soy or gluten.
Nutritional Value & Portion Size
Every Pete’s Paleo meal includes 5 to 5.5 oz. of protein and two 4 oz. sides, which should satisfy a diner with a healthy appetite. If you need more food, you can double the protein or add an extra side. The average calorie count is around 500 calories and the meals contain just the right quantities of fat, protein, and carbs.
Subscription Flexibility
With Pete's Paleo, you can skip a week, change your order or cancel anytime. All changes to your order must be made by Monday at midnight of the week that you’re scheduled to receive your order. Keep in mind that subscription plans can be paused or modified up to 3 times per quarter. Any additional changes come with a $15 administrative fee per request.
Refunds
For information about returns and refunds, you must contact Pete's Paleo directly.
Compare Plans & Pricing
ICON Meals Plans & Pricing
| ICON Meals Pricing | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Meal type | Price per meal | ||
| Signature meals | $7.00 - $11.00 | ||
| Custom meals | $8.50 - $19.50 | ||
| Custom breakfasts | $7.00 - $14.25 | ||
| Protein snacks | $9.99 - $28.00 | ||
| Food by the pound | $8.00 - $22.00 (per pound) | ||
Pete's Paleo Plans & Pricing
| Standard | ||
|---|---|---|
| Number of meals | Price | Price per meal |
| 5 | $123.00 | $24.60 |
| 10 | $189.00 | $18.90 |
| 14 | $249.00 | $17.78 |
| Family Plan (4 servings) | ||
| Number of meals | Price | Price per meal |
| 5 | $324.00 | $12.90 |
| Vegetarian | ||
| Number of meals | Price | Price per meal |
| 10 | $129.00 | $12.90 |
| Pete's Paleo Lite | ||
| Number of meals | Price | Price per meal |
| 7 | $99.00 | $14.14 |
| 21 Day Sugar Detox | ||
| Number of meals | Price | Price per meal |
| 7 | $147.15 | $21.02 |
| 14 | $241.65 | $17.26 |
| 21 | $315.00 | $15.00 |
Suitable For
Meals For Families
Meals For Kids
Meals For Seniors
Meals For One
Meals For Families
Meals For Kids
Meals For Seniors
Meals For One
Compare Meal Options
Vegetarian Meals
Vegan Meals
Paleo Meals
Keto Meals
Low-Carb Meals
Low-Fat Meals
Meals For Diabetics
Gluten-Free Meals
Organic Meals
Weight Loss Meals
Vegetarian Meals
Vegan Meals
Paleo Meals
Keto Meals
Low-Carb Meals
Low-Fat Meals
Meals For Diabetics
Gluten-Free Meals
Organic Meals
Weight Loss Meals
Compare Sample Meals
![Chicken rice veggies]()
- Chicken rice veggies
![Chicken tacos with a purple cabbage blend]()
- Chicken tacos with a purple cabbage blend
![Iiconcookie box triple chocolate]()
- Iiconcookie box triple chocolate
![Kobe meatballs in a bell pepper marinara]()
- Kobe meatballs in a bell pepper marinara
![21 Day Sugar Detox]()
- 21 Day Sugar Detox
![Black-Pepper-Tenderloin-with-Golden Beets and Sauteed Spinach]()
- Black-Pepper-Tenderloin-with-Golden Beets and Sauteed Spinach
![Coconut Curry Chicken Stew]()
- Coconut Curry Chicken Stew
![Petes Paleo Meals]()
- Petes Paleo Meals
Compare Extras
A La Carte Menu
Gift Cards
Marketplace
A La Carte Menu
Gift Cards
Marketplace
Compare Ratings
Compare Customer Reviews
- Submitted By Martha Ruiz on 05/07/2019I didn't love the meals at first sight, but they proved to be much tastier than they looked. The prices are really good compared to other services I've tried but yeah, $37 for shipping is a lot. I think I'll try the custom meals next time and then decide if it is worth the cash. Will update my rating if needed.
- Submitted By Mark R Berry on 10/09/2019Good food but sodium is way too high.
- Submitted By Allison on 05/19/2019Received a shipment a month or so ago that arrived warm. I mean this smelled bad inside the box. I threw the entire box away. Tried to get a refund, which turned into a massive ordeal. Sarah was so rude. We’ve ordered a ton from them in the past but I never will again in the future. For my family, customer service is the most important. If you’re big on customer service like I am, I would suggest finding meals elsewhere
- Submitted By Charles W. Burkett on 03/07/2019I've used this service for a while now and think that it's been been good. I had elected to try their double portions option and it was a good value as I received a double portion but not quite at double the price. The double portions, instead of coming in their traditional plastic plate, came in separate bags, which made it easy to use as much as you wanted and save the rest if you were not that hungry. I decided to order again, but received only the normal sized plastic plates. When I called to get the error corrected, I was informed that the plates which had the normal portions, were now holding the double portion. While there was a little for food stuffed onto the plates, it was not a double portion. I complained and had an email from Sarah, who identified herself as one of the owners, who basically told me that my eyes were wrong and it was a double portion. Obviously I'm disappointed for two reasons. One, the customer service is lacking but more importantly, two, that they would take advantage of a happy customer like this. Very disappointed.
- Submitted By Sevy Gambs on 01/01/2018I ordered my first shipment and did not realize the meals would be delivered not froze. One meal was partially frozen. I threw all meals away and asked my account be cancelled. I did not ask fr a refunds, as I threw the meals in the trash without fist calling and speaking with someone. I accept full responsibility for that mistake. However, I sent a total of 8 emails and three instant messages requesting cancellation of my account over a 3 day period without a response. I received an email letting me know my new order is being processed and my account has been charged. As a consumer Pete's Paleo website make it impossible to cancel ones account or stop shipment of an order without having to take additional time to submit an email or call. I can't speak to the quality of the meals, but do not recommend engaging their service unless you have time to dispute charges and take time out of your busy day to continuously follow-up with requests.
Winner
Pete’s Paleo is a meal delivery service that is committed to providing amazing Paleo dishes made with superior organic ingredients. They offer great meal plans, ready-to-eat meals for two major Paleo programs, their own bone broth and bacon and useful reading material and YouTube videos for anyone who wants to learn more about Paleo diet and cooking.